petrea_mitchell: (Default)
petrea_mitchell ([personal profile] petrea_mitchell) wrote in [community profile] agonyaunt2022-07-26 01:38 pm
Entry tags:

Why Tho? I’m sick of feeding other people’s kids

Could an admin-type person please create a "why tho?" tag?

Dear Lizzy,

We’re lower income. I’ve had a few different experiences that I don’t know how to deal with:

First, we invited my child’s classmate to come with us for a week at the beach. He was a huge eater. His parents did not offer to contribute in any way to meals, entry fees, or any other expenses. What is the etiquette/how do we ask parents to contribute next time?

Second, my middle school child made a plan for a mate to come over after dance class. In front of me and her child, the schoolmate’s mom handed her daughter a $20 bill saying, “This is to cover you if you go out for lunch.” We did go out to lunch, around the corner from a toy store. When the check came the mate pulled out the $20 bill, waved it a bit, looking me straight in the eyes, while saying, “Hey let’s go to the toy store.” Then she got up and headed to the toy store with the $20. This child has done this to me 3-4 times. She also routinely does it to my child if they go to Starbucks, etc. She pockets the money her (wealthy) parents give her to pay her share, saving it for things for her personal enjoyment, letting the other person pay her way.

Third, my child has a lot of friends and they like to hang out at our house. It’s not uncommon for there to be 4-5 kids over from the time school gets out until late at night on Friday and all day Saturday. I have never met these kids’ parents. I want to give my child dinner when dinner time rolls around, and his friends are hungry, too. Initially, I ordered pizza, wings, etc. to feed the whole crowd. I have now fed the whole crowd half a dozen Fridays in a row, and I hate that I’m feeling resentful. I want to feed my child, and I know these other kids also are hungry, but I just can’t afford to keep doing this. All these kids’ parents must know that someone is feeding their children week after week after week, but there’s no offer to contribute or reciprocate.

Suggestions?

Feeding Other People’s Children


Dear Feeding Other People’s Children,

I’m sorry you are feeling resentful, because I think with just a few changes in the way you are looking at this problem, you will see some really great things are happening here, you just need to change a few small things. Your children seem like they have a lot of friends who consider your home to be a safe and fun place to be. That’s amazing!

But, you need to start setting some boundaries and also start communicating, with your kids and with the parents of the kids’ friends.

First, I think if you invite another child on vacation, unless you have a very specific conversation during the invitation, you just have to expect you will be on the hook for all costs associated with the trip. So, if that’s not tenable, you either can’t bring other kids on vacation or you have to get comfortable with telling other parents that you would love for Johnny to come along but it’s going to be however much you determine a day. Unfortunately, you can’t be delicate or subtle about this and expect to get the money you need. You just have to ask.

The second problem is a bit more tricky, especially since both you and your child have developed a pattern of allowing this girl to walk all over you. It’s time for you to be more assertive and also teach your child to be more assertive. You need to tell her, next time, when the bill comes, “Can I have the $20 your mom gave you to pay for your food?” Or, tell the server you are on separate checks. Your child should also stop paying for her. Your child can just say, “Sorry my mom says I can’t pay for other people.”

Another option is to not invite this girl out to lunch or any other activities that require money, or any events at all actually because she seems like she isn’t treating you or your child with much respect.

And now, part three. You are definitely the fun house, where Mom is supplying yummy food and not even remotely in communication with other parents. It’s a party every weekend! I’d be there too! Step one, I think, is talking to your son about why these kids are coming over every weekend and how you two can work together to set limits for them (and him). Be honest with him – you can’t afford to feed this crowd of kids all the time.

Ask to meet your child’s friends’ parents. This will give you a better sense of the situation – are these kids not getting food at home? You also might be able to build a relationship with these parents and talk to them about occasionally hosting the gang.

You can set limits on how often your son can have friends over on Friday nights. Some nights it might just need to be family dinner night. It’s OK to set boundaries like that and it’s part of your job to teach your kids about boundaries and limits. It’s also perfectly reasonable to say, to your child’s friends, “It’s 6 p.m. and it’s a family dinner night so you all need to head home now!”

Set the expectation in advance, even before he goes to school on Friday.

And then stop ordering pizza and wings every time a crowd is over. Make a salad or PBJs. Buy some tortillas, beans and cheese and tell these, I’m assuming high school-aged, boys to make themselves dinner.

Ultimately, it seems like your kids are well-liked and their friends really like you and trust you and feel safe in your home. You can maintain that, but you need to take care of yourself too, and model good boundary setting for your children at the same time.

Good luck!

Lizzy
beable: (Default)

[personal profile] beable 2022-07-26 08:56 pm (UTC)(link)
I wonder if there is a big income divide (i.e. LW mentions being lower income but if the other friends/parents involved are not)

There's a lot of social/etiquette baggage about bringing up money in that situation, and at the same time if all the other parents are at a similar level of financial comfort where the crowd of teens wouldn't be a big deal it will never occur to them that LW isn't until LW brings it up.




Edited 2022-07-26 20:57 (UTC)
minoanmiss: A detail of the Ladies in Blue fresco (Default)

[personal profile] minoanmiss 2022-07-26 09:10 pm (UTC)(link)
I was just wondering this. And I was thinking... every time one asks someone something one risks them saying no. Have them say no often enough and one becomes The Person Who Needs To Be Said No To. If I were the LW I'd worry that the other parents would refuse to contribute financially and if I then told my children they couldn't have friends over I'd wreck their social standing.

Still, nothing ventured, nothing gained. People should think of this kind of thing but they don't. LW will have to ask. Good luck, LW, especially if you have less money than the other parents.
conuly: (Default)

[personal profile] conuly 2022-07-26 09:24 pm (UTC)(link)
In specifically situation 2, I do not understand at ALL why LW is:

a. continuing to allow that kid to come with them for lunch or
b. not saying directly "No, sweetie, your mother gave you that to cover your lunch. Pay for your lunch first, and THEN we will consider going to the toy store." Or, better yet, taking the money off of her right as her mom gives it to her and saying they'll "hold onto it" until Mom gets back. Then LW can give change and receipt to the other parent later.

As for situation 3, LW needs to find a few cheap and filling-but-boring meals and start making those week after week. Pasta with tomato sauce will fill a crowd on the cheap - especially if you either make the sauce yourself or buy the canned sauce instead of the jars - and while the kids will eat it, they won't come over just to have it. Alternatively, I actually have quite a wide repetoire of dishes that are basically cabbage + potatoes with optional ground beef/sausage and/or egg noodles and/or carrots. You cannot get cheaper than that, honestly, and none of these recipes taste bad, but nobody is going to ask for the recipe for their mom. They're just food to eat. Give 'em all apples for dessert and call it a day. (Edit: I forgot. You can get cheaper than that, and it's called "beans and rice". One week Mexican, another week Indian, just swap back and forth.)

Alternatively, they need to start sending these kids home half an hour before dinner time except when they've already decided in advance to feed them. You don't even need to talk to the parents. Just say "Welp, time to cook dinner, EVERYBODY OUT!" at a set time.
Edited 2022-07-26 21:28 (UTC)
castiron: cartoony sketch of owl (Default)

[personal profile] castiron 2022-07-26 11:18 pm (UTC)(link)
Yes, why doesn't LW say to parent of kid #2, "Hey, your daughter keeps taking the money you give her for lunch to go to the toy store and sticking us with the lunch bill, so we're not going to take her with us anymore"? I can understand LW being too taken aback the first time, but the second time, they needed to put their foot down, if not in the moment then when they next saw the parent. (Reading that description has me so angry that I'd have no problem using my mom voice on that kid if I were a stranger who'd witnessed the whole interaction.)
serriadh: (Default)

[personal profile] serriadh 2022-07-27 09:24 am (UTC)(link)
The other thing about this is the parent may assume you're ok with it. Presumably they have noticed that their daughter always comes back from lunch with you having a) had lunch and b) had money for a new toy as well. As the parents actually are giving the schoolmate money, I think it's fine to say 'Hey, this is a bit awkward but can I hold on to the lunch money this time? We're going past the toy shop and X has some formidable pester power. This way we can skip straight to using the lunch money for lunch."
green_grrl: (Default)

[personal profile] green_grrl 2022-07-27 03:55 am (UTC)(link)
As for situation 3, LW needs to find a few cheap and filling-but-boring meals and start making those week after week.

Yes. My first thought was start a crock pot of soup or chili Friday mornings, and there’s the kids’ dinner ready for that night.
tielan: (Default)

[personal profile] tielan 2022-07-26 10:49 pm (UTC)(link)
My problem is that i can see all the things that LW should be doing regarding setting boundaries, both financial and regarding their children, but to do so would require a) admitting financially straitened circumstances, b) saying 'no' to kids, whether their own or other people's kids.

I doubt that either of these is an option psychologically.
castiron: cartoony sketch of owl (Default)

[personal profile] castiron 2022-07-26 11:23 pm (UTC)(link)
I can see a), but b) is a huge part of the job of being a parent; if LW is having trouble saying no to their kids, they have bigger problems than the finances.
tielan: (Default)

[personal profile] tielan 2022-07-26 11:36 pm (UTC)(link)
Yeah, b) should be a big part of parenting, but I suspect that if you're in a), then doing b) might be difficult because if you can't give kids what they need materially then the drive to give them what they want psychologically is a bigger push.
castiron: cartoony sketch of owl (Default)

[personal profile] castiron 2022-07-26 11:45 pm (UTC)(link)
True.
ermingarden: medieval image of a bird with a tonsured human head and monastic hood (Default)

[personal profile] ermingarden 2022-07-26 11:41 pm (UTC)(link)
In situation #2, I think LW needs to tell the girl's parents what's going on; not just to fix LW's problem, but because that's the kind of dishonest behavior parents need to deal with before it snowballs. And LW wouldn't have to broach the topic of it being a financial hardship at all – it could just be phrased as "Here's something your daughter did that you really ought to know about."
serriadh: (Default)

[personal profile] serriadh 2022-07-27 09:26 am (UTC)(link)
Yeah, for situation #2, the framing could be "LW works with friend's parents to make sure she's spending the money on what they intended it for (aka lunch)" not "LW needs to tell friend's parents she can't keep paying for friend's lunch".
melannen: Commander Valentine of Alpha Squad Seven, a red-haired female Nick Fury in space, smoking contemplatively (Default)

[personal profile] melannen 2022-07-27 04:11 am (UTC)(link)
/me resists the temptation to mention Sweden in any way