ermingarden: medieval image of a bird with a tonsured human head and monastic hood (Default)
Ermingarden ([personal profile] ermingarden) wrote in [community profile] agonyaunt2022-04-12 10:38 am
Entry tags:

The Ethicist: Should I Have Lied to Help My Kid Brother Get Vaccinated?

My brother is 16 and lives with my parents. I am in my 30s and live several hours away. We have good relationships with one another, although my parents are extremely anti-Covid vaccine and anti-mask. They cannot be reasoned with over the issue.

After the Delta surge died down, I went home to visit. My brother — who is no rebel — asked for my help to get vaccinated because my parents would not let him.


I filled out the paperwork and accompanied him to the appointments as if I were his parent. This was illegal, but I thought it was the right thing to do. Although my brother is not legally an adult, he is competent to make this choice; if I had refused to help and my brother had become severely ill or died of Covid, I don’t know that I could have forgiven myself.

My parents just found my brother’s vaccine card, and the truth came out. They blame me, and I am second-guessing myself. Did I do the right thing? I thought so at the time. I realize now I should have tried to talk to them first (even if it was impossible to convince them), and I should have come clean to my parents after the fact. I have broken their trust, and my father isn’t speaking to me now.

Was I wrong? And more important, how do I fix this?
Name Withheld, Texas

The philosopher Ruth Chang has a theory about “hard choices.” Hard choices, in her account, arise when your options aren’t equally good but none is better overall. They’re good and bad in different ways.

You had sound reasons for making the choice you did. Your brother, you say, was competent to opt for vaccination, and in some states, he’d be legally entitled to. As his much older sibling, you rightly feel a special sense of responsibility when it comes to his care. The authorized Covid-19 vaccines are safe and effective at bringing down rates of infection and transmission and at significantly reducing the chance of serious illness. Your parents’ views on this topic are flatly wrong.

To be sure, a 16-year-old with no special medical conditions isn’t likely to suffer severe illness from Covid; your concerns for his welfare may have been overblown. Still, he should have been allowed to get vaccinated, whether to protect others or to alleviate his anxiety about his own risks. In helping him to make this happen, you were doing something your parents should have been willing to do for him — and for themselves and their community.

Yet had you declined to help your brother get vaccinated, you would have been justified too. It’s certainly a problem that what you did violated a reasonable law issued by a legitimate authority. And it was disrespectful to your parents; you indeed betrayed their trust, in defying their strong (albeit misguided) wishes.

To see it from your parents’ point of view, imagine that you have two kids. Your son wants to get treated by a traditional healer who serves a god your religion believes it is sinful to honor, and his big sister, who worships that god, too, arranges for this. She has provided a treatment for your son that served no purpose. Worse, she led him to betray his faith. It would be natural for you to feel resentment.

The point is that for some people, opposing what we know to be sensible public-health measures is central to their identities, in the way religion can be. That’s deeply unfortunate. But it’s important in understanding your parents’ reaction. If you had helped your brother get a fake ID, I suspect, your father might have been mad, but you’d be back on speaking terms. In this instance, you showed not only that you disagreed with your parents about their views but also, more wounding, that you didn’t trust them to look after your brother — to fulfill the basic responsibilities of parenting.

Many people are drawn to a bookkeeping model of morality: Tot up a row of numbers, determine whether there’s a plus or a minus in front of the sum and proceed with no regrets. Suppose that, owing to personal or public obligations, you have to tell a lie. The moral bookkeepers would assure you: The math works out, your conscience is clean, don’t give it a second thought. The greater wisdom is in both regretting the deception and understanding why it was justified. With hard choices, there’s no option that’s best in every way. We can, coherently, feel bad about actions we would not undo. It speaks well of you, as a loving child and as a caring sibling, that you’re uneasy.

I can see why you didn’t simply start by trying to persuade your parents to let your brother get vaccinated. You’ve plainly had unrewarding conversations with them about these issues and found that they are firmly in the grip of their delusions. Telling them about your intentions in advance would have been respectful but surely futile; indeed, they may have taken steps to keep your brother out of your hands. Still, if you hadn’t had a conversation in advance, it would, I agree, have been more respectful to come clean once it was done.

So tell your parents that you acted out of love and concern for your brother but that you understand and are sorry that you betrayed their trust. Of course, you’re sorry too that your parents have these gravely mistaken views — but you don’t need to say so, because they know it already.

Often we face choices where we can reason our way to one clear answer. We can then say that we’re “complying” with what moral reason dictates. But sometimes complexity swamps compliance: We simply have to turn inward for guidance and own our decisions. In fact, Chang argues, it’s when we’re making hard choices that we become “the authors of our own lives.” We decide what we’re for — we decide who we are. Helping your younger brother get vaccinated and setting out to repair your relations with your parents aren’t self-canceling impulses; they’re self-defining ones.
cimorene: cartoony drawing of a woman's head in profile giving dubious side-eye (Default)

[personal profile] cimorene 2022-04-12 03:00 pm (UTC)(link)
Agreed. She lays out the situation mostly correctly IMO, but the weight is wrong because of what you mention and also because she gives too little weight to the brother's choice. He is legally subject to his parents' wishes in this jurisdiction, but that doesn't give them an ethical right to endanger his health, let alone the consequences for the rest of society. Laws that allow parents to harm their minor children are ethically wrong laws, full stop, IMO. They should only impact ethical reasoning to the extent that violating them can have practical consequences.

I think her advice is good though, assuming he does prefer to have a positive relationship with his parents to the extent possible... although I would be more concerned that the brother is okay staying with them, tbh.
minoanmiss: Statuette of Minoan woman in worshipful pose. (Statuette Worshipper)

[personal profile] minoanmiss 2022-04-12 03:05 pm (UTC)(link)
because she gives too little weight to the brother's choice.

She doesn't seem to consider it at all! He's not a belonging the LW messed with, he's a person!

This letter has filled me full of exclamation marks.
cimorene: painting of a glowering woman pouring a thin stream of glowing green liquid from an enormous bowl (misanthropy)

[personal profile] cimorene 2022-04-12 03:10 pm (UTC)(link)
Yeah, point. The answer did make me angry for that reason. But maybe she was counting it as a win for him because he already got the vaccine and focusing solely on trying to explain the parents' probable POV, which no doubt is that gross given their reaction? The LW did mention his friendly relations with his parents, so that could have given her the idea it was the primary concern...

...very wrongly though, since the actual question was "Did I do the right thing" and the brother's agency is the central issue to that.
rmc28: Rachel in hockey gear on the frozen fen at Upware, near Cambridge (Default)

[personal profile] rmc28 2022-04-12 03:05 pm (UTC)(link)

Yep, I agree with you.

gingicat: deep purple lilacs, some buds, some open (Default)

[personal profile] gingicat 2022-04-12 03:44 pm (UTC)(link)
100%.
castiron: cartoony sketch of owl (Default)

[personal profile] castiron 2022-04-12 04:18 pm (UTC)(link)
And the people brother is protecting by getting vaccinated include the parents. If the parents get Covid in a later surge, the brother can take comfort in the fact that he did what he could to prevent that.
minoanmiss: Detail of a modern statue of a Minoan goddess holding up double axes in each hand. (Labrys)

[personal profile] minoanmiss 2022-04-12 03:04 pm (UTC)(link)
What is this bullshit. Appiah, I expected better.


To be sure, a 16-year-old with no special medical conditions isn’t likely to suffer severe illness from Covid; your concerns for his welfare may have been overblown


FFS.

LW, you did the right thing. I personally think that now what you have to decide is whether you will sacrifice some dignity and give your parents an apology they don't deserve in the hope of maintaining your relationship, or if you want to say to them, "You raised me to do the right thing and I did the right thing. When you want to talk to me I'll be here" and leave them alone for awhile. Sometimes in relationships we have to sacrifice some dignity to smooth things over -- it's a choice. But please, as you consider this choice, know that you're being the adult your parents don't want to be about this situation. You're the one willing to value love over pride. You did nothing wrong and your brother is lucky to have you.
Edited 2022-04-12 15:06 (UTC)
rmc28: Rachel in hockey gear on the frozen fen at Upware, near Cambridge (Default)

[personal profile] rmc28 2022-04-12 03:07 pm (UTC)(link)

I can think of one reason to attempt to smooth things over, which is to retain access and contact with the younger brother.

gingicat: deep purple lilacs, some buds, some open (Default)

[personal profile] gingicat 2022-04-12 03:44 pm (UTC)(link)
Honestly if I were the sibling I'd call CPS and try to get guardianship.
castiron: cartoony sketch of owl (Default)

[personal profile] castiron 2022-04-12 04:35 pm (UTC)(link)
CPS isn't going to be any help. If LW has money to throw at lawyers AND if brother wants LW as guardian, it *might* be possible to get guardianship, but it's still iffy; LW might be better off socking away that money to help brother in case brother wants to move out when he's 18.
conuly: (Default)

[personal profile] conuly 2022-04-12 08:39 pm (UTC)(link)
Child services isn't going to intervene with a 16 year old for anything that is not immediately life-threatening and also illegal. Not vaccinating isn't illegal. Perhaps if the parents had refused treatment for COVID CPS might get involved... but then again, maybe not.
green_grrl: (Default)

[personal profile] green_grrl 2022-04-12 05:17 pm (UTC)(link)
“I’m sorry I went behind your back to do something you were being completely unreasonable and, frankly, reckless about.”
librarygeek: cute cartoon fox with nose in book (Default)

[personal profile] librarygeek 2022-04-12 03:08 pm (UTC)(link)
And the LW never says that the 16 year old brother is otherwise healthy. I'm the eldest and 10 years older than my youngest sibling. If LW is in their 30s, then the parents are in their 50s at least. Brother was protecting the parents from additional exposure, too.

LW did the right thing. I know 20 year olds who have developed arrhythmias after an otherwise asymptomatic case of COVID. Living with a newly acquired heart condition because of a now preventable from severe illness virus is even harder on the teens and young adults. I've had heart disease from birth, I've been counseling that age group on what to watch for and report to cardiologist and ER as problematic symptoms.

My father just died in North Carolina. If the parents persist in being stupid, the LW might have guardianship of their brother before he's 18.
gingicat: deep purple lilacs, some buds, some open (Default)

[personal profile] gingicat 2022-04-12 03:45 pm (UTC)(link)
All of this.
minoanmiss: Minoan lady holding a bright white star (Lady With Star)

[personal profile] minoanmiss 2022-04-12 04:33 pm (UTC)(link)
I am sorry for your loss. Warm hugs if you would like.
librarygeek: cute cartoon fox with nose in book (Default)

[personal profile] librarygeek 2022-04-12 10:15 pm (UTC)(link)
Thanks. We lost our dad about 12 years ago, but my father's body just died, and now we get to mourn him. (Grief at losing our mom, posterior cortical atrophy, diabetic neuropathy, crazy Faux News watching second wife).

Yeah, all the Emotionally Complex Reactions, and I have seen anger and acceptance, but never bargaining or denial. 😵‍💫😖
melannen: Commander Valentine of Alpha Squad Seven, a red-haired female Nick Fury in space, smoking contemplatively (Default)

[personal profile] melannen 2022-04-12 05:48 pm (UTC)(link)
I don't get the point of the religion metaphor. Was that supposed to make me more sympathetic to the parents? It made me less. And I'm a church member.

(lw if your parents subscribe to an overbearing religion and your brother wants help getting out, do that too.)
lilysea: Serious (Default)

[personal profile] lilysea 2022-04-13 05:18 am (UTC)(link)
Given that there are young people with long-COVID severe enough to prevent working/studying who have not yet recovered THREE YEARS AFTER CATCHING COVID

LW ABSOLUTELY did the right thing!

How would LW feel if his brother had caught COVID, had become unwell enough to no longer be able to do school/paid work, with no idea when he would get better AND no good treatment options?

Because for a lot of young people who caught COVID, that was the outcome...
torachan: (Default)

[personal profile] torachan 2022-04-13 06:13 am (UTC)(link)
My workplace has had relatively few covid cases considering we are a supermarket and have constant exposure to a lot of people, but of the people who have gotten it, the one who developed long covid was only 21. He was previously fit and healthy and ended up with chronic fatigue and had to quit both work and school because he simply didn't have the energy to get out of bed most days. You really can't just assume that because someone is young and/or healthy they'll be fine, and it's infuriating to see the columnist perpetuating that.

(Among the many other infuriating things about their response...)
heavenscalyx: (Default)

[personal profile] heavenscalyx 2022-04-13 01:26 pm (UTC)(link)
I'm so goddamn ripshit about people minimizing risk from this thing. It is a SYSTEMIC INFLAMMATORY DISEASE. We have 2 solid years of data now that show that lasting damage occurs even in children, teens, and adults with asymptomatic infections. What little shitty reporting we have suggests that up to 30% of people with symptomatic infections may develop some kind of Long Covid. We have no reporting yet on how many extra strokes and other vascular events are killing or disabling people with and without symptoms, though what we have suggests that the coagulopathy can last around 2 months after symptoms abate. ARGH.

Even my normally fantastic PCP minimized it as "just some bad cold symptoms" and I am full of despair.