minoanmiss (![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
minoanmiss) wrote in ![[community profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/community.png)
agonyaunt2024-08-17 08:42 am
minoanmiss) wrote in agonyaunt2024-08-17 08:42 am
Ask Amy: A Toy Kitchen Brings Up Stereotype Questions
. My husband and I have a daughter, “Emma.” She is 3. We are thoughtful and responsible parents (at least we think so).
We have a question about gift-giving.
Our daughter goes to a nursery school program a couple of mornings a week, and it’s going very well. While at school, she loves to play with a miniature kitchen set. It’s got a little sink and a pretend stove with pots and pans.
We told my sister that we are thinking about getting a version of this for our daughter for Christmas (my sister also has children), but she is strongly disapproving because, as she says, this sort of toy “reinforces gender stereotypes.”
Now we feel weird about it and decided to seek your take.
WONDERING PARENTS
A. Many parents are concerned about reinforcing gender stereotypes … right up until that moment when their toddler son really loves to play with his cousin’s toy bulldozer, or their daughter falls in love with a Tiny Tammy doll.
Are you willing to deny your child the joy and learning experience of playing with an object she really loves in order to please your sister, or to pat yourselves on the back about adhering consistently to your powerful ideals? I hope not.
In my opinion, you have absorbed the very real issue of gender stereotyping in a sideways fashion. The idea is not to deny your child toys that are stereotypically associated with their gender, but to expansively offer them toys and experiences that are typically associated with any gender.
You might think of play (like gender) as occurring across a spectrum that the child has the power and autonomy to determine as they go — not the parents (or, for that matter, the marketing departments of toy companies).
And so, if your son wants a Tiny Tammy doll, he should receive it and be encouraged/allowed to play with it, and if your daughter chooses to wash her toy bulldozer in her pretend kitchen sink, then more power to her.
The boundary I would draw (this Christmas and on into the future) is around toys that encourage violence or mimic weaponry. (And yes, we all know that your daughter can pretend her wiffleball bat is a gun, but at the end of the day, she knows it’s a wiffleball bat.)
We have a question about gift-giving.
Our daughter goes to a nursery school program a couple of mornings a week, and it’s going very well. While at school, she loves to play with a miniature kitchen set. It’s got a little sink and a pretend stove with pots and pans.
We told my sister that we are thinking about getting a version of this for our daughter for Christmas (my sister also has children), but she is strongly disapproving because, as she says, this sort of toy “reinforces gender stereotypes.”
Now we feel weird about it and decided to seek your take.
WONDERING PARENTS
A. Many parents are concerned about reinforcing gender stereotypes … right up until that moment when their toddler son really loves to play with his cousin’s toy bulldozer, or their daughter falls in love with a Tiny Tammy doll.
Are you willing to deny your child the joy and learning experience of playing with an object she really loves in order to please your sister, or to pat yourselves on the back about adhering consistently to your powerful ideals? I hope not.
In my opinion, you have absorbed the very real issue of gender stereotyping in a sideways fashion. The idea is not to deny your child toys that are stereotypically associated with their gender, but to expansively offer them toys and experiences that are typically associated with any gender.
You might think of play (like gender) as occurring across a spectrum that the child has the power and autonomy to determine as they go — not the parents (or, for that matter, the marketing departments of toy companies).
And so, if your son wants a Tiny Tammy doll, he should receive it and be encouraged/allowed to play with it, and if your daughter chooses to wash her toy bulldozer in her pretend kitchen sink, then more power to her.
The boundary I would draw (this Christmas and on into the future) is around toys that encourage violence or mimic weaponry. (And yes, we all know that your daughter can pretend her wiffleball bat is a gun, but at the end of the day, she knows it’s a wiffleball bat.)
no subject
[1] Maybe not the alligator variant.
Ah, but Alligator! MinoanMiss would be a prestige ingredient forager, offering her fish and game Catch of the Day in return for the opportunity to taste the transformations wrought by human cookery. Maybe you’re a supplier for Tiana’s heirs (and how come the Disney Princess who’s canonically a chef doesn’t have a theme restaurant in the Magic Kingdom, particularly with authentic Creole and Cajun ingredients, chefs, waitstaff, and entertainers to be found right across the Gulf?)
no subject
AHAHAHAHAHAbwee. Thank you for this
Sent from my iPhone